The China-Plus-One sourcing strategy, the practice of diversifying manufacturing outside China while maintaining some Chinese production, has been the dominant supply chain narrative since the first Section 301 tariffs in 2018. Eight years later, the strategy has matured but grown more complicated. The Liberation Day IEEPA framework put a 10% baseline on almost every origin in 2025 until the Supreme Court ended it in February 2026, the Section 301 forced-labor action now adds 10% or 12.5% on 60 economies including Vietnam and India, and Mexico’s USMCA advantages came with intensified transshipment enforcement. For U.S. importers evaluating alternatives, the analysis requires a complete total cost of ownership model, not a simple tariff rate comparison.
Why China-Plus-One Remains Relevant in 2026
The effective tariff rate on most manufactured goods from China in 2026 combines MFN rates, Section 301 China rates (7.5% to 25%, up to 100% for strategic goods) and the 12.5% Section 301 forced-labor duty. Cotton sweaters (HTS 6110.20.20.79) pay 36.5% from China, 29% from Vietnam and 26.5% from India. The Section 301 tariffs on China alone eliminated the landed cost advantage for most mid-value manufactured goods; the IEEPA layer, which peaked at 145% in April 2025, made the arithmetic untenable for a much broader range of categories until it ended in February 2026. IEEPA duties paid in that period are refundable through CAPE, except finally liquidated entries without a Court of International Trade order.
The “Plus-One” in China-Plus-One does not mean complete exit from China. It means adding a non-Chinese manufacturing base to reduce tariff exposure on U.S.-bound goods while maintaining Chinese production for other markets or for products where no viable alternative exists (often advanced components or highly specialized manufactured goods).
Evaluating Vietnam
Talk to a senior trade strategist this week
A 30-minute working session to map your current tariff exposure, IEEPA refund options and DDP risk, then a clear action plan, not a sales deck.
Vietnam was the primary beneficiary of the initial China-Plus-One wave beginning in 2018-2019. Major electronics, apparel, and footwear manufacturers established significant Vietnamese production capacity during this period.
Current Tariff Exposure
Vietnam was assigned the highest Liberation Day Annex I rate of any major exporter, 46%, which was paused at 10% from April 10, 2025; all IEEPA rates ended in February 2026. Vietnamese goods now pay MFN plus the 12.5% Section 301 forced-labor duty, the same forced-labor rate as China, so Vietnam’s advantage is the Section 301 China list rate it avoids. One further Section 301 investigation that includes Vietnam, on structural excess capacity (91 FR 12886), remains pending, which creates uncertainty for long-term capital commitments.
Active AD/CVD orders cover Vietnamese solar cells, frozen fish fillets, shrimp, steel nails, wind towers and mattresses. For importers in these categories, the AD/CVD exposure on Vietnamese goods adds to the tariff burden and in some cases eliminates the Chinese tariff differential. Use the Captain tariff tracker to verify Vietnamese AD/CVD coverage for any specific HTS subheading.
Rules of Origin Considerations
Vietnam has no FTA with the United States, meaning Vietnamese goods receive MFN treatment at the base rate plus any applicable remedial tariffs. There is no preferential tariff layer that reduces the MFN base for Vietnamese-origin goods. For goods incorporating Chinese-origin components, transshipment rules apply: goods must undergo substantial transformation in Vietnam to qualify as Vietnamese origin. Simple assembly operations that do not meaningfully change the character of the goods do not confer Vietnamese origin; such goods may be assessed Chinese tariffs by CBP.
Landed Cost Assessment
Vietnam generally offers lower factory wages than China for labor-intensive products, partially offsetting the tariff differential. Logistics costs from Vietnam to U.S. ports are comparable to China for East Coast destinations via Suez routing and marginally higher for West Coast destinations. The supply chain infrastructure (ports, component suppliers, skilled workforce) is well-developed in Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi corridors for most categories that have already diversified there.
Evaluating India
India has positioned itself as a major China-Plus-One destination, particularly in electronics assembly, pharmaceuticals, textiles, and gems and jewelry.
Current Tariff Exposure
India was assigned a 26% Liberation Day Annex I rate, paused at 10% and later raised; all IEEPA duties on India ended in February 2026. Indian goods now pay the 10% Section 301 forced-labor duty, 2.5 points below Vietnam and China, and many pharmaceuticals on the note 52(b) list are exempt. India has no FTA with the United States under existing law. For current rates see current U.S. tariff rates by country.
Advantages for Specific Categories
- Pharmaceuticals and APIs: India is the world’s largest generic pharmaceutical exporter and a major active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) supplier. Many finished pharmaceuticals are exempt from the forced-labor duty, and Commerce has stated that Section 232 pharmaceutical tariffs do not apply to generics at this time (91 FR 60360).
- Textiles and apparel: India’s textile industry is among the world’s largest. Labor costs are competitive, and the supply chain for cotton and synthetic textiles is deep.
- Electronics assembly: Government incentive programs (PLI schemes) have attracted major electronics manufacturers including Apple suppliers to India. Quality and volume are ramping rapidly for mid-range consumer electronics.
Considerations
India’s infrastructure gaps (port congestion, power reliability, road logistics) outside major industrial corridors remain real cost factors. Lead times can be longer than China or Vietnam for certain product categories. The legal and regulatory environment for foreign investment requires more setup time than Vietnam or Mexico.
Evaluating Mexico (Nearshoring)
Mexico benefits from USMCA and geographic proximity to the U.S. market, making it the primary nearshoring destination for supply chains serving U.S. customers that require shorter lead times or just-in-time delivery.
USMCA Advantages
Goods that meet USMCA rules of origin qualify for zero or reduced MFN rates on entry to the United States, and USMCA duty-free goods are exempt from the 10% forced-labor duty that applies to other Mexican goods. This preferential treatment is unavailable to any Asian alternative. For products with zero USMCA tariff rates, the comparison with Vietnamese or Indian manufacturing is largely a logistics and factory cost comparison, not a tariff comparison.
Section 232 and Transshipment Risks
Mexico is subject to Section 232 duties of 50% on steel, aluminum and copper, with limited 25% quantities authorized by Commerce. More significantly, CBP has intensified enforcement of transshipment cases where Chinese-origin goods are imported into Mexico and re-exported to the U.S. without undergoing substantial transformation. Goods found to originate in China (based on production activity, not point of export) face the full Chinese tariff stack regardless of Mexican origin documentation. Importers sourcing from Mexican facilities that use significant Chinese-origin inputs must conduct rigorous origin analysis.
Landed Cost Assessment
Mexico’s advantages are proximity (2-3 day truck transit to most U.S. markets versus 20-30 days ocean from Asia), USMCA zero tariff (for qualifying goods), and a large, experienced manufacturing workforce in automotive, electronics, and consumer goods sectors. Factory labor costs are higher than Vietnam or India but significantly lower than U.S. manufacturing for most categories. The combination of zero tariff and proximity makes Mexico compelling for products with high tariff exposure and short-cycle inventory requirements.
Total Cost Framework: Beyond the Tariff Rate
Quantify your exposure in 20 minutes
Our trade strategists run your last 90 days of entries through Captain to surface refund eligibility, Section 232 traps and PNTR risk.
A complete China-Plus-One evaluation compares total landed cost, not just the tariff rate differential. The key variables are:
- Factory price difference: the cost premium or discount at the alternative origin versus China
- Tariff differential: current effective rate at alternative origin versus the China Section 301 stack
- Logistics cost difference: freight, transit time, inventory carrying cost, and service reliability
- Quality and volume ramp: time and cost to qualify the alternative supplier and achieve target quality and output volume
- Rules of origin compliance cost: investment in local content to meet FTA thresholds (for Mexico under USMCA)
- Tariff rate trajectory: expected rate at the alternative origin under ongoing negotiations versus China rate expectation
Our trade advisory services team builds multi-scenario total landed cost models covering these variables for specific product categories. The tariff consulting component covers the HTS classification, rules of origin analysis, and tariff rate scenario modeling for each candidate country.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the China-Plus-One strategy?
China-Plus-One is a supply chain diversification approach in which importers maintain some Chinese manufacturing capacity while adding at least one alternative manufacturing base outside China to reduce tariff exposure on U.S.-bound goods. The strategy became prominent after the 2018 Section 301 tariffs and intensified in 2025, when IEEPA duties on Chinese goods peaked at 145%. Those duties ended in February 2026, but Section 301 China rates and the 12.5% forced-labor duty keep China above most alternatives.
What is the current tariff rate on Vietnamese imports?
Vietnamese goods pay the MFN rate for the product plus the 12.5% Section 301 forced-labor duty, unless an exemption applies. The 46% Liberation Day rate assigned in April 2025 ended with the other IEEPA duties in February 2026. Active AD/CVD orders cover specific Vietnamese goods including solar cells, steel, and seafood. Check the Captain tariff tracker for current rates on specific HTS codes.
Does USMCA eliminate tariffs on Mexican goods?
USMCA eliminates MFN duties on qualifying originating goods from Mexico and exempts those duty-free goods from the forced-labor duty. Section 232 duties of 50% continue to apply to steel, aluminum and copper. Non-USMCA-qualifying goods pay the 10% forced-labor duty. Chinese-origin goods transshipped through Mexico without substantial transformation are subject to the full Chinese tariff stack regardless of point of export.
Is India a viable China-Plus-One alternative in 2026?
India is a viable alternative for specific categories including pharmaceuticals, textiles, and consumer electronics assembly. Its 10% forced-labor rate, below the 12.5% applied to Vietnam and China, and the exemptions for many pharmaceuticals make it attractively positioned on tariffs. Infrastructure gaps and longer ramp times are real considerations for industrial and high-precision categories.
What is transshipment in the context of China-Plus-One?
Transshipment refers to routing Chinese-origin goods through a third country (Vietnam, Mexico, etc.) without meaningful manufacturing transformation, to claim the third country’s more favorable tariff rate on U.S. entry. CBP applies the substantial transformation test to determine true origin. Goods that do not undergo substantial transformation in the transit country retain Chinese origin and are subject to the full Chinese tariff stack.
How do I evaluate total landed cost for alternative sourcing locations?
Total landed cost analysis compares factory price, tariff differential, freight and logistics cost, inventory carrying cost, quality ramp investment, and tariff rate trajectory for each candidate origin versus China. A tariff consulting engagement provides the tariff component; logistics and factory cost inputs come from your supply chain and procurement teams.
Build Your China-Plus-One Business Case
Sourcing diversification is a capital-intensive decision that requires rigorous analysis before commitment. Our trade advisory services team and tariff consulting practice provide the tariff rate analysis, rules of origin assessment, and landed cost modeling that make the China-Plus-One business case defensible to senior management and investors.


